Philosophy of Religion and Philosophical Theology: some ideas on drawing the demarcation
Keywords:Philosophy of religion, philosophical theology, religious studies, demarcation, subject-matter, methods, Vladimir Shokhin
AbstractIn this paper I consider two books of Vladimir Shokhin, a distinguished philosopher in Russia, on philosophy of religion (2010) and philosophical theology (2018) as one project aimed at drawing the demarcation between these two disciplines. In what follows I will present Shokhin’s project and show briefly how it fits in with the current discussion on the topic, then, draw some consequences from his position, and make some critical notes, and at the end I will briefly present some my views on the problem of drawing clear lines of demarcation between philosophy of religion and philosophical theology on the basis of the following questions: (1) what is the topic of the disciplines, (2) what are their methods, (3) what are their guiding lines, and (4) who may exercise them?
Baker-Hytch, Max. 2016. “Analytic Theology and Analytic Philosophy of Religion: What’s the difference?”. Journal of Analytic Theology 4, no. 1: 347–61. doi:10.12978/jat.2016–4.120023010007a.
Chantepie de la Saussaye, Pierre Daniel. 1897. Lehrbuch der Religionsgeschichte. Heidelberg: Mohr Siebeck Verlag.
Cornelis Petrus Tiele, Georg Gehrich. 1904. Grundzüge der Religionswissenschaft: Eine kurzgefasste Einführung in das Studium der Religion und ihrer Geschichte. Heidelberg: Mohr Siebeck Verlag.
Karpov, K. V., and T. V. Malevich. 2014. “Philosophy of Religion and Religious Studies in Modern-Day Russia”. Studies in East European Thought 66, no. 3–4: 227–44. doi:10.1007/s11212–014–9211–4.
Moore, Andrew. 2001. “Philosophy of Religion or Philosophical Theology?”. International Journal of Systematic Theology 3, no. 3: 309–20. doi:10.1111/1463–1652.00067.
O’Collins, Gerald G. 2010. “Review Article: Philosophical Theology, Philosophy of Religion, and Fundamental Theology”. Irish Theological Quarterly 75, no. 2: 217–24. doi:10.1177/0021140009361410.
Shokhin, Vladimir K. 2010. Philosophy of Religion and its Historical Forms (Antiquity — the End of XVIII Century). Moscow: Alpha-M.
—. 2018. Philosophical Theology: The Canon and the Variability. St. Petersburg: Nestor-history.