Religious Protest and Religious Loyalty


  • Avi Sagi Bar-Ilan University
  • Nir Sagi Kiryat Ono College



In the accepted view, the basic disposition of believers is one of absolute obedience, humility, and lack of critique, doubt, or, indeed, defiance of God. Only through such a disposition do believers convey their absolute faith and establish the appropriate hierarchy between God and humans. This article challenges this view and argues that, in mainstream rabbinic tradition, the believer is not required to renounce his or her moral autonomy and certainly not his or her understanding of God and the world. Indeed, faith rests on such understanding; moreover, human autonomy is the mechanism through which humans convey God’s goodness and perfection. Their questions and criticism are part of a persistent effort to close the evident gap between their assumptions about God’s goodness and the flawed imperfect reality. The analysis focuses on rabbinic tradition but its implications go beyond it, presenting a model of a life of faith that compels subjects, as believers, to preserve their constitutive foundations as rational autonomous creatures.


Bergman, Samuel H. 1976. “Kiddush ha-Shem (Hebrew)”. In ba-Mish`ol [On the Path], 182–90. Tel Aviv: Am Oved.

Berkovits, Eliezer. 1973. Faith after the Holocaust. New York, NY: Ktav.

— . 1979. With God in Hell: Judaism in the Ghettos and Deathcamps. New York, NY: Sanhedrin Press.

— . 1981. Halakhah: Its Power and Role (Hebrew). Jerusalem: Mosad Harav Kook.

— . 2010. God, Man and History. Jerusalem: Shalem Press.

Calvin, John. 1994. Institutes of the Christian Religion. Edited by Henry Beveridge. Grand Rapids, MI: WM. B. Eerdmans.

Frank, David A. 2004. “Arguing with God, Talmudic Discourse, and the Jewish Countermodel: Implications for the Study of Argumentation.” Argumentation and Advocacy 41, no. 2: 71–86. doi:10.1080/00028533.2004.11821620.

Goldman, Eliezer. 2009. Judaism without Illusion (Hebrew). Jerusalem: Shalom Hartman Institute.

Hartman, David. 1985. The Living Covenant: The Innovative Spirit in Traditional Judaism. New York, NY: Free Press.

Kook, Abraham Y. H. 1962–1965. Iggerot ha-Reayah, Vol. 2. (Hebrew). Jerusalem: Mosad Harav Kook.

— . 1963. Olat ha-Reayah, Vol. 1. (Hebrew). Jerusalem: Mosad Harav Kook.

— . 1964. Orot ha-Koddesh, vol. 3. (Hebrew). Jerusalem: Mosad Harav Kook.

— . 1995. Ein Ayiah: On the Rabbinic Legends in Ein Yaakov. Jerusalem: The R. Zvi Yehuda Kook Institute.

Laytner, Anson H. 1990. Arguing with God: A Jewish Tradition. Northvale, NJ: Aronson.

Leibniz, Gottfried W. 1985. Theodicy. Translated by E. M. Huggard. La Sale, IL: Open Court.

Leibowitz, Yeshayahu. 1976. “An Outline of the Jewish Religion Problem in the State of Israel (Hebrew)”. In Judaism, the Jewish People, and the State of Israel. Jerusalem: Schocken.

— . 1992. “Religious Praxis”. In Judaism, Human Values and the Jewish State, edited by Eliezer Goldman. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press.

Levinas, Emmanuel. 1990. Difficult Freedom: Essays on Judaism. Translated by Sean Hand. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Unive. Press.

London, Daniel. 2013. Fearless Prayer: Learning from the Jewish Tradition of Protest Against God: Meeting of the Society for the Study of Christian Spirituality: Univ. of Notre Dame, July 2 2013.

Midrash Genesis Rabba (Hebrew). 1965. Edited by J. Theodor and H. Albeck Wahrman. Jerusalem: Wahrmann Books.

Midrash Tanhuma-Yelammedenu. 1996. Edited by Samuel Berman. Hoboken, NJ: Ktav.

Mandelbaum, Dov, ed. 1987. Pesikta de-Rav Kahana. New York, NY: Jewish Theological Seminary.

Nietzsche, Friedrich. 2006. Thus Spoke Zarathustra: A Book for All and None. Edited by Adrian D. Caro and Robert Pippin. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.

Pesikta de-Rav Kahana. 1987. ed. Dov Mandelbaum. New York: Jewish Theological Seminary.

Sacks, Jonathan, ed. 2006. The Koren Siddur. Jerusalem: Koren.

— , ed. 2007. The Koren Rosh Hashana Mahzor. Jerusalem: Koren.

Sagi, Avi. 1992. “The Suspension of the Ethical and the Religious Meaning of Ethics in Kierkegaard’s Thought”. International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 32, no. 2: 83–103.

— . 1998. Judaism: Between Religion and Morality (Hebrew). Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuchad.

— . 2000. Kierkegaard, Religion and Existence: The Voyage of the Self. Translated by Batya Stein. Amsterdam: Rodopi.

— . 2006. The Jewish-Israeli Voyage: Culture and Identity (Hebrew). Jerusalem: Shalom Hartman Institute.

— . 2012. Halakhic Loyalty: Between Openness and Closure (Hebrew). Ramat-Gan: Bar-Ilan Unive. Press.

— . 2016. Prayer After the Death of God: A Phenomenological Study of Hebrew Literature. Translated by Batya Stein. Boston, MA: Academic Studies Press.

Sagi, Avi, and Daniel Statman. 1995. Religion and Morality. Translated by Batya Stein. Atlanta, GA: Rodopi.

Schweid, Eliezer. 1994. To Declare that God is Upright: Theodicy in Jewish Thought (Hebrew). Bat-Yam: Tag.

Sifre: A Tannaitic Commentary on the Book of Deuteronomy. 1986. Translated by Reuven Hammer. Yale University Press.

Underhill, Evelyn. 1973. Worship. New York, NY: Harper and Row.

Uzziel, Ben Z. H. 1991. Derashot Uzziel, Avot. Jerusalem: Va`ad le-Hotsa’at Kitvei ha-Rav.

Verbin, Nehama. 2017. “Three Knights of Faith on Job’s Suffering and its Defeat”. International Journal of Philosophy and Theology 78, no. 4–5: 382–95. doi:10.1080/21692327.2017.1284606.

Weinberg, Yehiel Y. 2003. Li-Frakim [At Times] (Hebrew). Jerusalem.

Weltsch, Felix. 1920. Gnade und Freiheit: Untersuchungen zum Problem des schöpferischen Willens in Religion und Ethic. München: Kurt Wolff.

Wiesel, Elie. 1995. All Rivers Run to the Sea: Memoirs. New York, NY: Alfred A. Knopf.



How to Cite

Sagi, Avi, and Nir Sagi. 2020. “Religious Protest and Religious Loyalty”. European Journal for Philosophy of Religion 12 (2):7-36.