Theism & Evolutionary Debunking Arguments Against Moral Realism
Evolutionary debunking arguments against morality come in a variety of forms that differ both in how they take evolution to be problematic for morality and in their specific target of morality i.e. objectivity, realism, justification for moral beliefs, etc. For the purpose of this paper, I will first articulate several recent debunking approaches and highlight what they take to be problematic features of evolutionary history for morality. In doing so I will be forced to abstract from some of the specific arguments offered, although I will provide replies to particular aspects of the arguments offered by Michael Ruse, Sharon Street and Richard Joyce. Then, I will show that theists have independent reasons for rejecting certain, core assumptions of these debunking approaches, thus deflating the major thrust of debunking worries for morality. While there may be good responses available to the non-theist realist with respect to several of the worries raised below, this paper will simply show why the theist need not be troubled by contemporary debunking approaches against morality.
Blount, Zachary D., Richard E. Lenski, and Jonathan B. Losos. 2018. “Contingency and Determinism in Evolution: Replaying Life’s Tape”. Science (New York, N.Y.) 362, no. 6415: 5979. doi:10.1126/science.aam5979.
Darwin, Charles. 1888. The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex. London: John Murray.
FitzPatrick, William J. 2015. “Debunking Evolutionary Debunking of Ethical Realism”. Philosophical Studies 172, no. 4: 883–904.
Geach, P. T. 1956. “Good and Evil”. Analysis 17, no. 2: 33–42.
Gould, Stephen J. 1991. “Interview: Stephen Jay Gould, Evolutionary Biologist and Paleontologist”. Academy of Achievement, 1991.
Joyce, Richard. 2006. The Evolution of Morality. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Laland, Kevin N., Tobias Uller, Marcus W. Feldman, Kim Sterelny, Gerd B. Müller, Armin Moczek, Eva Jablonka, and John Odling-Smee. 2015. “The Extended Evolutionary Synthesis: Its Structure, Assumptions and Predictions”. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 282, no. 1813. doi:10.1098/rspb.2015.1019.
Ruse, Michael. 1986. “Evolutionary Ethics: A Phoenix Arisen”. Zygon 21, no. 1: 95–112.
Shafer-Landau, Russ. 2012. “Evolutionary Debunking, Moral Realism and Moral Knowledge”. Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy 7, no. 1: 1–38.
Sripada, Chandra S., and Stephen Stich. 2006. “A Framework for the Psychology of Norms”. In The Innate Mind: Culture and Cognition, edited by Peter Carruthers, Stephen Laurence and Stephen Stich. New York, NY: Oxford Univ. Press.
Street, Sharon. 2006. “A Darwinian Dilemma for Realist Theories of Value”. Philosophical Studies 127, no. 1: 109–66.
Thomson, Judith J. 1997. “The Right and the Good”. The Journal of Philosophy 94, no. 6: 273–98. https://www.jstor.org/stable/2564542.
—. 2008. “Turning the Trolley”. Philosophy & Public Affairs 36, no. 4: 359–74.
Wong, T. Y. W. 2019. “The Evolutionary Contingency Thesis and Evolutionary Idiosyncrasies”. Biology and Philosophy 34, no. 2: 22.