Moral Discernment and Doubt in the Human Journey
An ongoing challenge within all approaches to ethical decision making is reducing the degree of doubt about what action is right, good, or at least better in a given situation. The process of moral discernment within Christian thought is no exception; however, different Christian communities tend to understand moral doubt and moral certainty differently, to pursue different ways of allaying doubt, and to expect—and accept—different degrees of moral certainty. Drawing especially from Aristotelian virtue theory, selected teachings from the Eastern Orthodox tradition on humility, and recent discussions of the ‘grace of self-doubt,’ I sketch an account of virtuous moral doubt as a mean between the extremes of excessive and deficient moral doubt. My hope is doing so will help to make space and provide the framework for an ecumenical understanding of doubt’s proper role in moral discernment.
Basil of Caesarea. 1962. St Basil: Ascetical Works. Edited by Sister M. M. Wagner. Washington, D.C.: The Catholic Univ. of America Press.
Bedke, Matthew. 2018. “Cognitivism and Non-Cognitivism”. In Routledge Handbook of Metaethics, edited by Tristam McPherson and David Plunkett, 292–307. London: Routledge.
Cahill, Lisa. 1984. “Contemporary Challenges to Exceptionless Moral Norms”. In Moral Theology Today: Certitudes and Doubts, edited by Rev. G. Donald, 121–35. Saint Louis, MO: Pope John Center.
Conroy, J. O. 2019. “The life and death of John Chau, the man who tried to convert his killers”. The Guardian, February 3, 2019. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/feb/03/john-chau-christian-missionary-death-sentinelese.
DeYoung, Rebecca. 2009. Glittering Vices: A New Look at the Seven Deadly Sins and their Remedies. Grand Rapids, MI: Brazos Press.
Dorotheos of Gaza. 1977. Discourses & Sayings. Edited by Eric P. Wheeler. Kalamazoo, MI: Cistercian Publications.
Farley, Margaret. 2002. “Ethics, Ecclesiology, and the Grace of Self-Doubt”. In A Call to Fidelity: On the Moral Theology of Charles E. Curran, edited by James Walter and Timothy O’Connell, 55–75. Washington, D.C.: Georgetown Univ. Press.
Fullam, Lisa. 2011. “Humility and Its Moral Epistemological Implications”. In Virtue: Readings in Moral Theology No. 16, edited by Charles E. Curran and Lisa Fullam, 250–74. New York, NY: Paulist Press.
Gustafson, James. 1979. Protestant and Roman Catholic Ethics. London: SCM Press.
Hamalis, Perry. 2012. “Ethics”. In The Orthodox Christian World, edited by Augustine Casiday, 419–31. London: Routledge.
Häring, Bernard. 1990. “The Role of the Catholic Moral Theologian”. In Moral Theology Challenges for the Future: Essays in Honor of Richard A. McCormick, edited by Charles Curran, 32–47. New York, NY: Paulist Press.
Hofer, Andrew. 2008. “The Humble Speech of the Lord: Revelation and Conversion According to St. Ephrem”. Pro Ecclesia 17, no. 2: 224–42. doi:10.1177/106385120801700206.
Ingham, Mary B. 2008. “Moral Decision-making as Discernment”. In Moral Action in a Complex World: Franciscan Perspectives, edited by Daria Mitchell, 121–42. St. Bonaventure, NY: Franciscan Institute Publications, St. Bonaventure Univ.
Trowbridge, Richard H., and Michel Ferrari. 2011. “Sophia and Phronesis in Psychology, Philosophy, and Traditional Wisdom”. Research in Human Development 8, no. 2: 89–94. doi:10.1080/15427609.2011.568847.
Vlahos, Hierotheos. 2008. Orthodox Psychotherapy. Pelagia, Greece: Birth of the Theotokos Monastery Publications.
Ward, Benedicta, ed. 1984. The Sayings of the Desert Fathers. Kalamazoo, MI: Cistercian Publications.
Ware, Kallistos. 1990. “Foreword”. In Spiritual Direction in the Early Christian East, edited by Irénée Hausherr. Kalamazoo, MI: Cistercian Publications.
— . 2000. “The Spiritual Guide in Orthodox Christianity”. In The Inner Kingdom: Volume One of the Collected Works, edited by Kallistos Ware, 127–51. Crestwood, NY: St. Vladimir’s Seminary Press.
Wasik, Zdzisław. 2019. “Ethics and Morality as Axiological and Praxeological Semiospheres of Culture: First Steps to a Conceptual Framework”. Argumentum: Journal of the Seminar of Discursive Logic, Argumentation Theory & Rhetoric 17, no. 2: 91–111.
World Council of Churches. 2013. Moral Discernment in the Churches: A Study Document, Faith and Order Paper no. 215. Geneva: World Council of Churches Publications.