The Ill-Made Knight and the Stain on the Soul


  • Michael Rea



atonement, stain on the soul, narrative, self


One of the main tasks for an account of the Christian doctrine of the atonement is to explain how and in what ways the salvifically relevant work of Christ heals  the damage wrought by human sin on our souls, our relationships with one another, and our relationship with God. One kind of damage often neglected in philosophical treatments of the atonement, but discussed at some length in Eleonore Stump’s forthcoming At-one-ment, is what she, following St. Thomas Aquinas, calls the stain on the soul.  The stain on the soul comprises the “moral leftovers” of serious evil, damage to the soul that goes beyond the guilt, shame, and separation from God brought about by sin and that lingers in a person even after she has repented and been forgiven. In this paper, I critically examine Stump’s account of how the work of Christ deals with the problem of the stain on the soul. I offer reasons for thinking that if the stain is exactly as she describes it, then it is indelible; and then I explore possible ways forward for her account of the atonement.


Adams, Marilyn McCord. 1990. “Horrendous Evils and the Goodness of God”. In The Problem of Evil, edited by Marilyn McCord Adams and Robert Merrihew Adams, 209–221. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.

— . 2003. “In Praise of Blasphemy!” Philosophia no. 30: 33–49. doi:10.1007/ BF02383299.

— . 2006. Christ and Horrors: The Coherence of Christology. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.

Greenhoot, Andrea Follmer, Shengkai Sun, Sarah L. Bunnell, and Katherine Lindboe. 2013. “Making Sense of Traumatic Memories: Memory Qualities and Psychological Symptoms in Emerging Adults with and without Abuse Histories”. Memory no. 21: 125–42. doi:10.1080/09658211.2012.712975

Habermas, Tilmann, and Christin Köber. 2015. “Autobiographical Reasoning Is Constitutive for Narrative Identity”. In Oxford Handbook of Identity Development, edited by McLean, Kate C. and Moin Syed, 149–65. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.

McAdams, Dan P. 2001. “The Psychology of Life Stories”. Review of General Psychology no. 5: 100–122.

— . 2008. “Personal Narrative and the Life Story”. In Handbook of Personality: Theory and Research, edited by Oliver John, Richard Robins, and Lawrence Pervin, 3rd edition, 242–62. New York: Guilford Press.

McLean, Kate C. 2015. The Co-Authored Self: Family Stories and the Construction of Personal Identity. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.

McLean, Kate C., and Dan P. McAdams. 2013. “Narrative Identity”. Current Directions in Psychological Science no. 22: 233–38.

McLean, Kate C., Monisha Pasupathi, and Jennifer Pals. 2007. “Selves Creating Stories Creating Selves: A Process Model of Self-Development”. Personality and Social Psychology Review no. 11: 262–78.

Panchuk, Michelle. 2018. “The Shattered Spiritual Self and the Sacred: Philosophical Reflections on Religious Trauma, Worship, and Deconversion”. Res Philosophica no. 95: 505–30. doi:10.11612/resphil.1684

Rea, Michael. 2018. The Hiddenness of God. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.

Schechtman, Marya. 1996. The Constitution of Selves. Ithaca: Cornell Univ. Press.

— . 2014. Staying Alive: Personal Identity, Practical Concerns, and the Unity of a Life. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.

Singer, Jefferson. 2004. “Narrative Identity and Meaning Making Across the Adult Lifespan: An Introduction”. Journal of Personality no. 72: 437–60. doi:10.1111/j.0022– 3506.2004.00268.x

Stump, Eleonore. 2018. Atonement. Oxford: Oxford Univ. Press.

White, T. H. 1940. The Ill-Made Knight. New York: G.P. Putnam’s Sons.



How to Cite

Rea, Michael. 2019. “The Ill-Made Knight and the Stain on the Soul”. European Journal for Philosophy of Religion 11 (1):117-34.